Skip to content
MythosPedia

Egyptian artifact

the Benben


The most influential object in Egyptian architectural history is missing, and has been for a very long time. The benben was a stone kept in the temple of Ra at Heliopolis. No description of it survives from anyone who saw it, no image of it can be certainly identified, and it disappeared along with the rest of the temple, which is now almost entirely gone beneath the northern suburbs of Cairo.

What survives is everything it generated.

The mound

Egyptian creation accounts share one image across their otherwise incompatible systems: at the beginning there is only Nun, the undifferentiated waters, and the first thing to exist is a mound of land rising out of them. On that mound the creator stands, or the sun first appears, and everything follows.

The benben is that mound, made permanent as a cult object. Its name is generally connected to the verb weben, "to rise" or "to shine forth", the word used of the sun coming up, which makes the object's name a description of what it commemorates. Egyptian texts also link it to Atum, who is said to have appeared as or on the benben, and to the Bennu bird, which alights on it.

The one solid thing about its physical form is its shape. The word is used for pointed or conical stones, and the derived term benbenet is the technical name for the pyramidion — the small pointed capstone that finished a pyramid or an obelisk. Whether the original was a conical stone, a squat pointed block, or something else is not recoverable from the sources.

What Egypt built from it

Two of the most recognisable forms in world architecture derive from it.

Obelisks are the more direct descendants. An obelisk is a single tapering shaft of stone, square in section, cut from one piece — the granite quarries at Aswan preserve an unfinished example still attached to the bedrock, cracked and abandoned, which would have been over forty metres long and around a thousand tonnes had it been extracted. The point at the top is a benbenet, and it was frequently sheathed in electrum or gold so that it caught the first and last light of the day. The shaft is the rest of the sunbeam.

Obelisks were erected in pairs at temple entrances, and they carry royal inscriptions down all four faces. More Egyptian obelisks now stand outside Egypt than in it — in Rome, which has the largest number and took them as imperial trophies from the reign of Augustus onward; in Paris, London, New York and Istanbul, mostly through nineteenth-century diplomatic gifts and removals. The Lateran obelisk in Rome, originally from Karnak, is the tallest standing anywhere.

Pyramids are the more debated case. The pyramidion finishing a pyramid is called by the same term, several survive, and some are inscribed with solar texts — the pyramidion of Amenemhat III from Dahshur carries an inscription about the king's face being opened to see the lord of the horizon. The argument that a pyramid is a monumental primeval mound, and that its shape represents the descent of sunlight, is well established and reasonable. Whether the whole form was conceived from the benben, or whether the benben association was applied to an existing form, is not settled — the first pyramid, Imhotep's step structure at Saqqara, developed out of a mastaba tomb by enlargement rather than being designed as a solar symbol from the start.

Heliopolis

The city where the stone was kept, Egyptian Iunu and biblical On, was one of the oldest and most prestigious religious centres in the country and the home of the Ennead — the theological system running from Atum through Shu and Tefnut down to Osiris and his siblings, which became the standard framework for Egyptian religion generally.

Almost nothing of it is visible. A single standing obelisk of Senusret I, erected around 1950 BCE, remains in situ in the Matariya district — the oldest obelisk still standing in its original position anywhere. The rest of the site was quarried for building material over centuries, and modern Cairo has grown over it. Excavation continues in the surviving open plots and has produced colossal statuary, including fragments of a large Psamtik I figure recovered from groundwater-flooded ground in 2017.

The disproportion is worth stating: the theology that shaped Egyptian religion for three thousand years came from a city of which one obelisk and a set of excavation trenches remain.

The mystery-literature version

The absence of the object has made it attractive to speculative writing, which has variously identified it as a meteorite, as an iron-nickel mass, as a piece of extraterrestrial technology, or as a lost artefact with unusual properties. The meteorite suggestion is the only one with any texture to it: Egypt did use meteoritic iron, and Tutankhamun's dagger blade has been shown by X-ray fluorescence analysis to be of meteoritic composition, so the culture had access to and interest in iron from the sky. That establishes that Egyptians used meteoritic material. It establishes nothing about the benben, for which no compositional evidence of any kind exists because the object does not.

The honest summary is that we know its name, its approximate shape, its theological function and its architectural legacy, and we do not know what it was made of, what it looked like, or where it went. The methodology page sets out why this site prefers to state that plainly rather than to fill the gap.

Questions about a missing stone

Is the pyramidion of the Great Pyramid still around?

No. The capstone of the Great Pyramid at Giza is missing, along with nearly all of the fine white Tura limestone casing that once covered the whole structure — most of which was stripped in the medieval period for building in Cairo. Whether the Great Pyramid was ever finished with a pyramidion at all is a genuine question; some Egyptologists doubt it. Pyramidia from other pyramids do survive, including a fine black granite example of Amenemhat III now in the Egyptian Museum.

Why were obelisk tips gilded?

To make the point flash. The shaft would be in shadow while the tip caught the sun at dawn and dusk, and Egyptian texts describe the effect in solar terms. Inscriptions record the quantities of electrum used, and Hatshepsut's obelisk texts at Karnak claim the tips could be seen from a distance across the river. It is a deliberate optical effect built into monumental architecture.

Did other cities have their own benben stones?

Sacred stones of comparable type are attested elsewhere, and the benbenet form was reproduced constantly in miniature — small stone pyramidia were placed on private tomb chapels at Deir el-Medina and elsewhere, giving an ordinary workman's tomb the same solar finish as a royal monument. The Egyptian tradition hub covers this pattern of royal forms filtering down the social scale, which is one of the clearest long-term trends in Egyptian religion.

Elsewhere in Egyptian mythology